Elwood Shelton is an online content developer for Gun Digest. I understand that there is a huge difference between 9mm and 10mm. They put forth the request for a weapon, capable of stopping a horse? This is on south Texas deer. And in the long run, it will prove cheaper to shoot. The original specs were supposed to be a 200-grain bullet at 1,000 fps with 444 ft-lbs of energy. Why the 10mm Is the Ultimate Handgun Cartridge for Hunting and Personal Defense (Plus 8 of the Best Pistols You Can Buy) If you are looking for a hybrid pistol with stopping power that’s capable of killing big game, the 10mm is your best bet. That's a vast difference in handgun type too, comparing a 10+1rd semi auto with a 6 shot single action! Disclosure: Some of these links are affiliate links. Please try again. Alien Gear Holsters is bent on crafting the worlds best concealed carry holsters on the planet. There is a lot to like. 10mm vs. 357 Mag Muzzle Energy. The quick version is the 10mm has a longer case, but the .45 ACP has a larger projectile. However, you get a bit more carrying capacity with a 10mm...a whopping 1 more round in single-stack magazines and 2 more in double stacks. Economical and excellent up close, the .45 ACP is an exceptional choice for a self-defense, plinking and competition. In the Philippines, it is referred to as the Philippine American war. I, respectfully, would like to share an alternate historical view? While the Taurus Raging Bull is available in a wide variety of barrel lengths and … In recent years, at least among those with a yen for powerful semi-automatic pistols, a gauntlet of sorts has been laid down: 10mm vs .45 ACP. Lower-recoil, lower-power loadings - often called "FBI loads" - are quite popular. If just punching targets, .45 ACP is better on paper. The .357 Magnum is a powerful cartridge, but in this case it takes a narrow 2nd place to the 10mm Auto. The long he heralded Glock safe action also tops the list. 2019 Alien Gear Holsters. The 10mm also has a shorter bullet. 10mm has been used to stop animals as large as bears. This caliber offers substantial power and penetration that’s beyond the 45 ACP and 9mm. However, how much of a difference is there between 9mm and .45 ACP? 3. 10mm capacity is not a problem for the Glock 20. Not exactly ideal in the FBI's eyes, who adopted it for a short time in the 1980s and 90s. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Jun 24, 2018 #1 . Load up on the right 6.5 PRC ammo and you take your shooting to a new level. In the skilled hands, the .45 ACP absolutely sings. Handloads push the .45 Super further. You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. It’s significantly more powerful, rivaling even the hottest .357 Magnum loads and approaching lighter .41 Magnum levels. In either case — and like with all guns and cartridges — you should practice due diligence. Even today, if I have to defend my life, hand me a revolver. I feel comfortable and safer with this method -- no worries of accidental trigger pull during my draw. Things are brighter on the ammo horizon, there are more choices, and, as mentioned before, it perhaps has more handloading potential. But a slower .45 JHP for self defense is more practical for my needs . eval(ez_write_tag([[728,90],'gundigest_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_5',128,'0','0'])); Purpose designed as a man stopper, the .45 ACP has shined in the role for more than century. It's also easier to shoot. At the extreme end, such Winchester’s Ranger T-Series, the projectiles are fully capable of mushrooming to 1 inch in diameter. At that, darn few compacts are chambered for this round, so a 10mm CCW gun involves some very limited choices. I was 100% sure that that revolver was going to go off at least a time or two and that was all I needed. And while Col. Jeff Cooper’s darling has never become quite the belle the .45 Auto has remained, it certainly has turned heads enough to become a consideration among those who yearn for big and bad. Standard bearer statue achieved, it continues today as a favorite of armed citizen and a law enforcement alike, offering manageable power with proven results. Wala – .45 1911. The 10mm has a faster velocity and energy than the.45ACP. Because if you ham a bystander most DA’s will do what ever they can to put your head on the chopping block . eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'gundigest_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_7',149,'0','0']));Given the cartridge is in its renaissance, you’re also limited in your pistol choices. The iconic 1911 still soldiers on, not only made by Colt, but a slew of other manufacturers — Kimber, Springfield, Remington, SIG Sauer and many more. 9mm vs. 45 ACP vs. 10mm Discussion in 'Semi-Auto Handguns' started by Striker9Mil, Jun 24, 2018. Many shooters find it comparable to a firm but steady push as opposed to the "snap" of the .40 S&W. Taurus Raging Bull. JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser. The original 200-grain loads screamed from the muzzle at 1,200 fps, with a bone-crushing 759 ft-lbs of energy. Double-tap ammo is good stuff, and gets al the potential from the cartridge. It's cheaper to buy (a box of 50 practice rounds goes for $30 or more in 10mm; in .45 ACP, about $17) and there are more guns offered in that chambering. The new kid on the block, an oddity at that, the 10mm never really got out of the shadow of the grand old .45 ACP. Not too many years ago, availability would not have been an argument, the .45 ACP would have been the clear winner. It's a big, slow-moving bullet. Then the 10mm round itself had its issue. Of the more notable are the Ruger SR1911, SIG Sauer P220, Remington R1 Hunter, Dan Wesson Bruin and Springfield Armory 1911 TRP RMR. Since it fills certain niches, not every round is suitable for every application. There are others, of course. As hot handloads of 10mm nips at the .41 Magnum's heels, the .45 Super comes close to the lower end of .45 Colt +P and .44 Magnum loads. Even with similar bullets, however, it appears the 10mm … I prefer the 10mm for carrying if I am n the woods, in the city, the .22 LR Walther PPK is my favorite. Given its long lifespan, there are simply more pistol options to choose from for the .45 ACP. The answer — like everything in the gun world — isn’t as clear-cut as simply jumping on one team or the other. Only it requires more time and effort to become truly proficient with, outside its lightest loads. Great, except for the fact that if they jammed on the job, you couldn't raise your hand and have the range master stop the shooting.. This is especially the case if you opt for a smaller-framed model. Roughly, it would achieve 20-percent more velocity at the muzzle than the .45 and flirt with doubling its energy. It has greater velocity, which means it’ll be more accurate over longer distances. Compared to big-bore revolver rounds, it's cheap to shoot at less than $20 per box of 50 of modest quality hardball. Are you open to my suggestion, that there or more than one view? Definitely, it’s the choice if you’re aiming at handgun hunting or need protection against four-legged predators, instead of simply two. 7 Considerations To Find The Best Concealed Carry Pistol, Modern Shooter: The Magic Of Turnbull Restoration Company, A Perfect 10: Top 10mm Pistol Options (2020), Best 10mm Ammo For Self-Defense And Hunting (2018), Kicked To The Curb: Tales Of Recoil And Pain, 45ACP Winchester 185gr Silvertip JHP 20 Rounds $20.19, 9mm Sellier & Bellot 124gr FMJ 50 Rounds $31.99, 9mm Winchester 115gr FMJ 100 Rounds $69.99, 9mm Federal 150gr Synthetic Jacket 50 Rounds $39.99, 00 Buckshot Black Aces Tactical 12 Gauge 2.75" 250 Rounds $249.99, 9 Affordable Double-Barrel Shotgun Options (2020), 8 Budget AR-15 Options: More Bang For The Buck (2020), Best Concealed Carry Handguns For Women (2020), 6 On-Target Concealed Carry Insurance Options (2020), Handgun size (.45 has more compact options), Price per round (one is a bit more spendy than the other). Yes it is...and no it isn't. So, the 10mm is great if you want a gun that will do it all but don't mind some kick when shooting or when at cashier of the gun store. The.40 is as stated a shorter version of the 10mm. A family of Sig Sauer V-Crowns, left to right: 9mm 124-grain, .40 S&W 180-grain, 10mm 180-grain, .45 ACP 230-grain. Chris Mudgett. My father, who served 3 tours of duty in Vietnam, told me that they used to stage midnight raids on Vietnamese supply dumps, when they could locate them, just to get hold of the PPS 43-C Tokarev autos and ammo because they were so much more reliable than Stoner's Tupperware rifles. An interesting twist, while the 10mm is still popular as a self-defense option, it has punched a toehold in the hunting world. What is the best price for 10mm Vs 45 Ammo And 12 Gauge Shotgun Shells Ammo You can order 10mm Vs 45 Ammo And 12 Gauge Shotgun Shells Ammo after check, compare What you like most and shoot best is the one to acquire. The 10mm and 45 have nearly the same recoil if you are shooting 45+p which is what I shoot in my defensive loading. If you're in the market and weighing the 10mm vs .45 ACP, the question shouldn’t be “Which one should I buy?” That will get you nowhere. https://www.wideopenspaces.com/10mm-vs-45-acp-which-one-is-right-for-you Let's go over that a little more. Not a screamer, but it hits hard for a semi-auto. Caribou Media Group may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. That question came up in the mid 80’s when the 10mm was the hot new round that people were all talking and writing about. You can load it light for practice or even for carry, or load it hot and heavy for use in the backcountry or if you don't mind a stout carry load. Nope!! The bigger, slower, heavier .45 ACP is a pure personal protection round. 9mm vs .40 vs .45 Debate | Which Is Better for Self-Defense? June 23, 2020. The 10mm is also one of the few mainstream semi-auto handgun rounds that's well-suited to hunting, as small to medium game (up to hogs and deer) are well within its capabilities. This means bullets go faster! The idea eventually transformed into the 10mm and became a reality when he teamed up with gunmaker Dornaus & Dixon and Swedish ammo manufacturer Norma. Eventually matched with his legendary 1911 pistol, the cartridge and handgun went on the make history. You don’t get to be as choosy. As you can see the table below, both of these statements are true. Shop for Low Price 45 Colt Bulk Ammo And 10mm Vs 45 Acp Ammo .Price Low and Options of 45 Colt Bulk Ammo And 10mm Vs 45 Acp Ammo from variety stores in usa. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps. I have no problem with C/C because I have large hands and the large frame Glocks fit me nicely. That frontal diameter is the difference in my opinion and of course my personal handloads. The Colt Delta Elite was not only the first 10mm 1911 but the second gun ever … Truthfully, all of these calibers are awesome. Because of its higher muzzle energy, higher velocity and better ballistic coeffic… Difficult to say why shooters have re-kindled love for the nearly forgotten handful (most likely versatility), but in the past few years the market has responded. Shooting a .45 might also mean shooting a 1911, which of course is the perfect gun one of the quintessential handguns of all time. I do, however, favor a Tokarev semi, they are well made, powerful as hell, and I've never had one jam on me. There is, of course, a cost to the larger round in weighing 10mm vs 9mm. eval(ez_write_tag([[728,90],'gundigest_com-box-4','ezslot_6',104,'0','0']));Furthermore, the .45 ACP's common use also gives it the advantage of ample handguns and ammo options. 1911s are 7 and 8 round mags. The round was imagined by Col. Jeff Cooper - he who wrote down the 4 Laws of Gun Safety - and Dornaus and Dixon, a boutique gun company, cooked up the Bren Ten (an over-bored, dressed-up CZ-75) to shoot it with and Norma set about making the ammo. Striker9Mil Active Member. Bottom line, 10mm is a great round, capable at a LOT of things, and exceeds .45-acp by a decent margin, however, that margin can also be filled by .45-Super by a pistol made to work with it. Is the 10mm bigger than the 45? “If your answer isn’t ‘Give me one of each!’ then you need a long hard chew on what you plan to do with your new 10mm or .45 ACP before getting one.”. The classic loading is a 230-grain ball that travels around 830 fps, carrying about 350 foot-pounds of energy. So now I've got a Glock 20-SF w/ a 9" Lone Wolf barrel 10mm... and a Star Megastar 45 which handles .45 … Copyright © Certainly out of most pistols it generates more recoil than say the 9mm, but not a universe more. When it was invented, the .45 ACP round was essentially .45 Colt with a shorter, rimless case to fit in a semi-automatic pistol. While research is required to ensure satisfactory penetration from a defensive round, most bullets they're loaded with have mind-blowing expansion potential. Ammo, at least at time of writing, is abundant and easy on the pocketbook. Thank you! However, said bullets also go faster because they are smaller; the standard .45 ACP load is 230 grains compared to the standard 180 grain projectile in 10mm. 10mm Vs .45 ACP: Making the Right Choice Glock 10mm Pistols : The Stalwart Option Because we’re looking at the bear-busters—the hunting loads here—I’ll leave the defensive ammo subject with one simple suggestion: Hornady 175-grain Flexlock Critical Duty. It isn't that one is "better,": it's more that one is better for certain tasks than the other. Which will be, though? So, as you can see, the 10mm isn't as big around, but generates more than 1.5 times the chamber pressure of the .45 ACP. In essence, it may be the perfect auto-loading round...though it comes with some costs. And the recoil was none too easy on the guns either, with a tendency to break them down before their time. In turn, the U.S. Military went searching for a more substantial replacement. Well, the question is "better for what?" It's also worth noting, however, that you can get very close to 10mm power with .45 ACP+P loadings. However, said bullets also go faster because they are smaller; the standard .45 ACP load is 230 grains compared to the standard 180 grain projectile in 10mm. The chamber pressure - less than 23,000 psi in most chamberings - is very moderate among the popular defensive calibers as well, meaning that .45 ACP pistols will often have long service lives. Sure it does...head shots and other central nervous system hits happen. The .45, however, gives you more choice in pistols, costs less to run and is generally easier to shoot but is best suited to range work and carry. If it was good enough for them then, it's good enough for me now.. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'gundigest_com-leader-1','ezslot_4',107,'0','0']));Conversely, if you have a yen for a handgun that reaches out, hits hard and — if you happen to reload — has more room to work with, your money might be better spent on a 10mm. It excels at penetrating soft tissues and creates marginally larger wound channels, even with hardball, than smaller rounds. The Achilles’ heel of the cartridge, the further you have to shoot, the more difficult it is to achieve accuracy — the .45 drops, a lot, fairly quickly. There are other issues that We, as Americans, tend to slant our philipine history, but that is for another day, another way. When not at his press or the range he can be found chasing mule deer around the Rocky Mountains. If that's you, then get what your heart desires and have fun. I guess you had to be there. There has always been a debate over the best caliber for self-defense. The vast majority of other shooters can master it. The 10mm, with all its potential, looked ready to fade away from early glory, following the likes of the .44 Auto Mag and other powerhouse semi-auto cartridges. In FBI testing, a 170-grain JHP from Norma ended up with the best “Wound Value” score. 2. Get the 74th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. Recoil is ample but far from unmanageable, especially in a larger pistol. You can get more in a magazine with the 40 and 10. A sledgehammer hunting round, such as Buffalo Bore’s 220-grain Heavy Outdoorsman, will make a hole in an attacker, no doubt. The longer version goes a little more like this: So, as you can see, the 10mm isn't as big around, but generates more than 1.5 times the chamber pressure of the .45 ACP. 230gr .45's are the same as 180gr .40/10mm and the 250gr .45 is about the same as the 200gr .40/10mm. Generally speaking, if you want power in a handgun, a 10mm is a very destructive and powerful caliber, but the .45 acp is also powerful and more popular for self-defense. Only after you drop the hammer will you know if you have found the right gun and cartridge. To assuage my lingering guilt, I rationalized I could duplicate my departed 10mm if I loaded my Glock with.45 ACP+P ammunition. All Rights Reserved.